UK retailers failing to convert one-time buyers into loyal customers

UK brands and retailers are failing to covert one-time buyers, some pushed online for the first time during lockdown, into frequent purchasers through a lack of loyalty programmes and personalised content, according to data from dotdigital, the leading omnichannel marketing automation platform.

Original research in the Hitting the Mark report, which benchmarks the digital marketing tactics adopted by 100 global ecommerce brands, shows that despite the rising cost of customer acquisition, 80% of UK brands and retailers haven’t adopted a loyalty programme into their customer marketing strategy, missing a key opportunity to create the emotional connection necessary to drive customer lifetime value.

Addressing the data gap

43% of brands fail to collect key customer data, such as date of birth, at the earliest stage of acquisition, meaning retargeting strategies lack the personalisation needed to drive ongoing engagement.  This comes at a time when customers’ expectations have been elevated by the Covid-19 lockdown as shoppers had time to make more considered purchases and, the more brands did for them during the difficult times, the more customers have come to expect.

Getting past the five-purchase loyalty threshold

39% of shoppers say it now takes five or more purchases before they consider themselves loyal to a brand.  However, once loyal, 35% of consumers will spend more with a brand even when there are less expensive options elsewhere and 56% will refer a brand to their friends and family.

One answer to the challenge of keeping a customer coming back to push past the five-purchase threshold is the development of a personalised loyalty programme built on customer insight and data, as Mark Jervis, Marketing Director, at dotdigital explains:

“Creating a loyalty programme that is as thoughtful, delightful, and on-brand as the rest of your customer experience is a key pillar of a customer-centric marketing strategy, enabling retailers to make customers feel valued.  Retailers should move beyond the traditional ‘points for purchase’ model and tailor their programme to build an emotional bond based on customer insight.  Shoppers want to earn credit by taking actions other than making a purchase, so offer points for reviews and interactions with their social channels.”

Using reviews to drive repeat purchases

Post-purchase, customer reviews increase shoppers’ trust in a brand, giving a greater incentive to return.  Currently, 60% of UK brands request post-purchase reviews and over half of them use an independent platform to power these requests which is important as customers are more inclined to share their experiences via a third-party platform.

“Globally, the UK leads the way in omnichannel marketing, with retailers scoring highly against key success metrics when compared to other markets.  However, despite these advances, retailers and brands are still missing opportunities to get closer to their customer by not embedding loyalty into their selling strategies.  Therefore, retailers are losing out on a significant chunk of revenue potential in the market and customer loyalty remains fickle”

Mark Jervis, Marketing Director, at dotdigital 

For more actionable insights on the strategies ecommerce professionals and marketers are utilising globally, and what this means for retailers and business leaders looking to build these capabilities in to their operations, download the full report: Hitting the Mark, Global Ecommerce Benchmark Report 2020

Join Retail Connections

Register here

Related insights


The future for brands is brighter outside retail

Retailers braced for festive shopping frenzy

Counting the cost of poor online experiences in peak


Christmas ads betray a lack of awareness of the public mood


Frasers Group, where distressed brands go to live

Checking in – the hospitality trends powering the industry’s covid-19 recovery

Join Retail Connections

Get the latest industry views and exclusive member offers sent direct to your mailbox.